Skip to content
SUBMIT
PAPER
About Us
About APJYS
Editorial Board
Journal Committee
Journal Info
Aim and Scope
Journal Policies
Submission Guidelines
Copyright Form
Disclaimer
E-ISSN / ISSN
FAQ
Collection
Current Issues
All Issues
Archived
Register
Author Registration
Reviewer Registration
Contact Us
Login
Search this website
Menu
Close
About Us
About APJYS
Editorial Board
Journal Committee
Journal Info
Aim and Scope
Journal Policies
Submission Guidelines
Copyright Form
Disclaimer
E-ISSN / ISSN
FAQ
Collection
Current Issues
All Issues
Archived
Register
Author Registration
Reviewer Registration
Contact Us
Login
Executive Editor Evaluation Form
ASIA PACIFIC JOURNAL OF YOUTH STUDIES (APJYS)
EVALUATION FORM
(Evaluation form are confidential and the contents are not to be revealed to other persons)
Hidden
Manuscript Number
Manuscript ID
Title of Manuscript
(Required)
Hidden
Start Date
DD slash MM slash YYYY
Date of Evaluation
DD slash MM slash YYYY
Hidden
Meeting's Name
Year
Volume
Issue
Hidden
Original Manuscript
Accepted file types: doc, docx, Max. file size: 50 MB.
Hidden
Edited Manuscript
Accepted file types: doc, docx, Max. file size: 50 MB.
A. PLEASE EVALUATE THE MANUSCRIPT BASED ON THE FOLLOWING SCALE:
1 = Poor
2 = Below Average
3 = Average
4 = Good
5 = Excellent
1
2
3
4
5
1) The article title is appropriate.
(Required)
2) The topic of the article is relevant to the field of the journal.
(Required)
3) The manuscripts meets the aims and scopes of the journal.
(Required)
4) The study presents the results of original research.
(Required)
5) Objectives and justifications clearly stated.
(Required)
6) Theoretical/ Conceptual Framework.
(Required)
7) Statement of the problem.
(Required)
8) Significance of research is explicitly stated.
(Required)
9) Literature review explained clearly.
(Required)
10) Research Methodology
(Required)
(The research methodology for the study is appropriate and applied properly)
11) Quality of data/ findings.
(Required)
12) Research results
(Required)
(Results reported have not been published elsewhere)
13) Conclusions
(Required)
(Presented appropriately and supported by the data)
14) Readability and Writing Style
(Required)
(The paper has clarity of presentation. It is well organised and clearly written)
15) Implications and recommendations for management are relevant and useful.
(Required)
B. ORIGINALITY OF THE PAPER AND ITS CONTRIBUTION TO THE FIELD
None
Trivial
Modest
Important
Very
Significant
Contribution to the field
(Required)
C. OVERALL COMMENTS AND IMPRESSIONS
(Required)
D. OVERALL EVALUATION
(Required)
Accept article and send to reviewers for peer-reviewing process
Reject Article
Further Comments Regarding on Rejection of the Article:
(Required)
Hidden
Manuscript Link